With a runner on first base (R1), the pitcher attempts to pick-off R1. The pitcher's throw to first base bounces past the first baseman and rolls to the fence, but remains in live-ball-territory.

 

R1 runs toward second base. The shortstop is worried that R1 may try to advance to third base, so the shortstop positions himself exactly as he would if he were receiving a throw. He slaps his glove, puts it on the ground, and tags R1 without the ball.

 

R1 believed the shortstop had the ball (or was about to receive it), so R1 slid into second base instead of rounding the base. Meanwhile, the first baseman retrieved the bad pick-off throw. He does not throw the ball to attempt to retire R1. It is unlikely that R1 would have attempted to go to third base, and if he had attempted, he likely would have been put out.

 

Which of the following apply (may be more than one)?

 

A) This is nothing, play on. It is R1's responsibility to know when he is being played on.

B) This is obstruction. R1 should be awarded the base he is going to (2nd base) plus one (3rd base)

C) This is obstruction, R1 should be awarded 2nd base

D) This is a fake tag and the shortstop should be ejected (restricted to the bench) for this conduct

E) The coach should be restricted to the bench for the shortstop actions

F) The defensive team should receive a team warning and the next player on that team that fake tags should be ejected.